Join WhatsApp
Sample output Ā· AI-generated

Your prompt: "Write a LinkedIn post about my promotion."
What you wanted: a humble, warm post
What you got: a long, boastful post full of buzzwords

| Part | Score | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Clear goal | 3 | You want a post, but not the feeling it should leave. |
| Context | 1 | No role, company type, years of work or people to thank. |
| Specific details | 1 | The AI had to invent everything. |
| Output format | 1 | No length or structure. |
| Rules and limits | 1 | Nothing about tone or words to avoid. |
| Examples | 1 | No sample of a post you like. |

Biggest weakness
There is no tone or detail, so the AI fell back on the typical announcement style: long, formal and full of buzzwords.

Three small edits
1. Before: "about my promotion"
After: "about my promotion to Senior Analyst after 3 years at a logistics company"
2. Before: (no tone)
After: "Tone: humble and warm. Thank my team lead, Neha, and my teammates."
3. Before: (no length)
After: "Under 120 words, 3 short paragraphs, no hashtags except #NewRole."

Rule to remember
The AI fills every gap with the most common style. Name the tone and give one real detail, and the result will sound like you.

Text prompt Ā· ChatGPT Ā· Claude Ā· Gemini

Prompt critique prompt: score your prompt and learn why

Get honest, specific feedback on any prompt you wrote: a score on six parts, the biggest weakness and small edits to fix it.

Act as a prompt-writing teacher. Review the prompt below and help me learn to write better prompts myself.

My prompt: [paste it]
What I wanted: [the result you hoped for]
What I got instead: [what went wrong, or "not tried yet"]

Score my prompt from 1 to 5 on each of these: Clear goal, Context, Specific details, Output format, Rules and limits, Examples. Show it as a table with a one-line reason for each score.

Then:
1. Name the single biggest weakness and explain how it likely caused the problem.
2. Show 3 small edits, each as Before and After, instead of rewriting everything.
3. Give me one general rule to remember for next time.

Be direct but kind. Do not write a whole new prompt unless I ask.
Type
Text
Fill in
3 blanks
Copies
Be the first

Updated Ā· By

Tip: Run your three most-used prompts through this review once; the fixes will improve everything you write after.

1. CopyTap "Copy prompt" above.
2. Fill the blanksReplace each [bracket] with your own details.
3. Paste + refinePaste it into the chat, then ask for changes.

Why this prompt works

A prompt critique teaches you more than a rewrite does, because it shows which parts of your prompt were weak and how they caused the result. Scoring six parts, from the goal to examples, gives you a simple checklist you can run in your head next time.

The three small before-and-after edits keep your own words and show how little needs to change. Asking for one general rule at the end turns each review into a habit you keep.

How to use this prompt

  1. Tap "Copy prompt".
  2. Replace every part in [square brackets] with your own details.
  3. Paste it into ChatGPT or Claude and send.
  4. Ask a follow-up like "make it shorter" or "give me 3 more options" to fine-tune it.

Variations to try

Compare two prompts

ChatGPT Claude Gemini
Here are two prompts for the same task: [prompt A] and [prompt B]. Score both on the same six parts, say which will likely give a better result and why, and suggest one line from each to combine.
Type
Text
Fill in
2 blanks
Copies
Be the first

Critique my prompt for a beginner

ChatGPT Claude Gemini
Review this prompt as if I am new to AI tools: [paste]. Use no jargon. Tell me the 2 most important things to add and show the prompt with only those 2 changes.
Type
Text
Fill in
1 blank
Copies
Be the first

Make it your own

  • Add "I am using it for [task]" so the scores reflect what matters for that task.
  • Ask for "a score out of 30 at the end" to track your progress over time.
  • Add "Also check for anything that might confuse the AI" for long prompts.

Common problems and fixes

  • The AI rewrites the whole prompt anyway. Keep "Do not write a whole new prompt unless I ask" and add "keep my words where possible".
  • Every score is high, even for a weak prompt. Add "Be strict; a 5 means nothing could be improved".

FAQ

Is a higher score always better?

Not for every task. A quick question does not need examples or a format. Use the scores as a guide, not a test.

How is this different from the prompt improver?

The improver writes a better prompt for you. This one explains what is weak so you learn to fix it yourself.

More How to write prompts

See all
ChatGPT Claude Text prompt

Improve my prompt: an AI rewriter that asks questions first

Paste any rough prompt; the AI asks a few questions about what is missing, then rewrites it into a clear, structured prompt.

3 prompts
ChatGPT Claude Text prompt

How to write image prompts: a helper prompt for any idea

Turn a one-line idea into three detailed image prompts that cover subject, setting, light, style, colours and aspect ratio.

3 prompts
ChatGPT Claude Text prompt

Prompt template builder for tasks you repeat every week

Turn a task you do every week into a fill-in-the-blank prompt you can reuse, with a filled-in example and a quick checklist.

3 prompts
ChatGPT Claude Text prompt

Role prompting: set up an expert persona for better answers

Set up a detailed expert role before you ask your real question, so the AI answers at the right level, in the right tone and format.

3 prompts
ChatGPT Claude Text prompt

Step by step prompt for careful answers to tricky problems

Make the AI slow down on tricky problems: restate the question, list assumptions, solve in numbered steps and check the answer another way.

3 prompts