Why this prompt works
A prompt critique teaches you more than a rewrite does, because it shows which parts of your prompt were weak and how they caused the result. Scoring six parts, from the goal to examples, gives you a simple checklist you can run in your head next time.
The three small before-and-after edits keep your own words and show how little needs to change. Asking for one general rule at the end turns each review into a habit you keep.
How to use this prompt
- Tap "Copy prompt".
- Replace every part in [square brackets] with your own details.
- Paste it into ChatGPT or Claude and send.
- Ask a follow-up like "make it shorter" or "give me 3 more options" to fine-tune it.
Variations to try
Compare two prompts
- Type
- Text
- Fill in
- 2 blanks
- Copies
- Be the first
Critique my prompt for a beginner
- Type
- Text
- Fill in
- 1 blank
- Copies
- Be the first
Make it your own
- Add "I am using it for [task]" so the scores reflect what matters for that task.
- Ask for "a score out of 30 at the end" to track your progress over time.
- Add "Also check for anything that might confuse the AI" for long prompts.
Common problems and fixes
- The AI rewrites the whole prompt anyway. Keep "Do not write a whole new prompt unless I ask" and add "keep my words where possible".
- Every score is high, even for a weak prompt. Add "Be strict; a 5 means nothing could be improved".
FAQ
Is a higher score always better?
Not for every task. A quick question does not need examples or a format. Use the scores as a guide, not a test.
How is this different from the prompt improver?
The improver writes a better prompt for you. This one explains what is weak so you learn to fix it yourself.